Regulating AI Warfare

January 14, 2025

Regulating AI Warfare Article thumbnail. It is an AI generated image of a robot holding a weapon in the middle of the desert.
Regulating AI Warfare

Artificial Intelligence (AI) can be effectively used to help alleviate multiple challenges.  Its application in medicine, science, climate change, economic and social wellbeing, etc. can enhance the overall condition of humanity.  There is, however and of course, always a flipside to the constructive application of technology that has the potential of transforming and reshaping global dynamics. 

The article titled “Gaza – Ground Zero for AI Warfare” by Ozer Khalid published in this issue of Criterion Quarterly warns us, through recent examples in Gaza, of the catastrophic devastation that can be caused through the indiscriminate use of AI in warfare.  The author states: “no matter how much AI advances, the humans must, at all times, remain an integral part of the AI decision making process.  It is a fatal flaw to circumscribe a human’s role to just ratifying or rubber-stamping AI verdicts.” 

The theme (self-explanatory through the title) was so intriguing that a mere abstract did not suffice, and a more detailed note or comment had to be written.

A futuristic scenario/warning on similar lines was highlighted by Henry A. Kissinger, et al. in the book ‘The Age of AI And Our Human Future.’ They wrote:

“Once AI’s performance outstrips that of humans for a given task, failing to apply that AI, at least as an adjunct to human efforts, may appear increasingly as perverse or even negligent.  Whether an individual playing AI-assisted chess might be counseled to sacrifice a valuable piece that sophisticated players had traditionally deemed indispensable is of little consequence, but in the context of national security, what if AI recommended that a commander in chief sacrifice a significant number of citizens or their interests in order to save, according to the AI’s calculation and valuation, an even greater number?  On what basis would that sacrifice be overridden? Would the override be justified?  Will humans always know what calculations AI has made? Will humans be able to detect unwelcome (AI) choices or reverse unwelcome choices in time?  If we are unable to fathom the logic of each individual decision, should we implement its recommendations on faith?  If we do not, do we risk interrupting performance superior to our own?  Even if we can fathom the logic, price, and impact of specific alternatives, what if our opponent is equally reliant on AI?  How will the balance between these considerations be achieved or, if necessary, vindicated?”

Till we answer the questions mentioned above, we need to be vigilant in the use AI technology for national security.  For this a set of globally accepted norms, regulations and protocols need to be established and implemented.

The underlying impulse, however, that will hinder efforts to regulate and accelerate the proliferation of AI technology in warfare is predicated on one of the questions quoted above: “…what if our opponent is equally reliant on AI?”  Being better than those deploying these systems will be the driving force for an AI arms race.

Whenever new technology that can alter global power dynamics is introduced into an existing geopolitical ecosystem, a certain level of absurdity, driven by competition and building a capacity to dominate, can be expected before some level of sanity prevails. During the cold war arms race, for instance, the global nuclear weapons stockpile had reached 60,000 in the 1980s.  Although still dangerously high, the number in early 2024 was just over 12,000. Can the world afford such an escalation in this new AI arms race?

In addition, the inability to assess the capabilities of other nations accelerates threat perceptions.  The doctrine of Mutually Assured Destruction (MAD) has remained a major factor in not using nuclear weapons.  There is no such deterrence in the development and deployment of AI in warfare.  It is, therefore, imperative that unilateral and multilateral norms, regulations and monitoring/implementing authorities are established.

Global regulations and protocols pertaining to AI technology are still in their infancy.  It is difficult to predict what the next breakthrough in AI will be and when it may occur.  The regulating apparatus in countries, no matter how advanced they are, in its existing form, cannot keep pace with the rate at which this technology is progressing.   Nasruminallah Mian writes in his article “The Public Policy Sandbox” (this issue of CQ): “…policies can last for decades with minor adjustments… according to a study, the mean lifespan across the world since 1789 is a mere 17 years.” Regulatory authorities must now be agile and willing to adapt “at the speed of Moore’s law” to be effective.

Thomas Friedman, in his book ‘Thank You for Being Late’, gave the example of how some educational institutions are managing the fast pace of technology advancement.  He wrote:

 “Rather than expecting new regulations to last for decades, it (institution including the major government regulatory body) should continuously reevaluate the ways in which they serve society. Universities are now experimenting with turning over their curriculum much faster and more often to keep up with the change in the pace of change—putting a “use-by date” on certain courses. Government regulators need to take a similar approach.  They need to be as innovative as the innovators.”

The general outlook towards regulations is not favorable as they are considered a hindrance to freedom, progress, innovation and entrepreneurship. However, the unpredictable nature of AI technology and its potential requires prudent policymaking and supervision.

Furthermore, AI technology does not operate in a vacuum.  The values, priorities and aspirations driving societies will dictate how this new technology will be used.  The general trend that we can gather from events in 2024 is that of conflicts and polarization. Within this context, and the potential of escalating turmoil, the need for multilateral supervision becomes essential.

The question arises: Who will lead the world in developing and implementing global regulations?  The world order, in its present state, is complicated.  There seems to be a global leadership vacuum. The US is moving away from the post-cold war global world order that it had established. The shift away from multilateralism and towards a more transactional and unilateral approach may, in the short-term, work for the great powers, however, the weaker states that have relied on the liberal global system and its institutions will be vulnerable.  The middle powers are generally preferring to stay on the sidelines and not get entangled in the great power rivalry that is emerging. In addition, the two countries that are leading the AI arms race and who can actually make a difference, are on opposing sides.

The global dynamics mentioned above suggest that, in 2025 and beyond, an unfettered AI arms race will continue in the absence of an “adequate regulatory environment”—at least till an event of sizeable magnitude and repercussions forces a priority realignment of world leaders.

Regulating AI Warfare: The Ethical Imperative to Halt an Unchecked Arms Race

Related Articles

Quiet Diplomacy: Pakistan’s Pivotal Role in the US-Iran Peace Process

Quiet Diplomacy: Pakistan’s Pivotal Role in the US-Iran Peace Process

Pakistan’s role in facilitating dialogue between the United States and Iran is examined against the backdrop of a conflict that threatened regional stability and the global economy. This comment explores how the closure of the Strait of Hormuz elevated the crisis from a regional confrontation to a matter of international concern, while highlighting Pakistan’s emergence as an effective middle power through quiet diplomacy and strategic engagement. It argues that Islamabad’s unique relationships with Washington, Tehran, Beijing, and Gulf capitals enabled it to play a pivotal role in reducing tensions and advancing negotiations at a critical moment for the region.

The Indo-Pak Battlefield of Competing Narratives

The Indo-Pak Battlefield of Competing Narratives

This article on Indo-Pak relations examines how competing narratives, hybrid warfare, and media propaganda are shaping diplomatic outcomes between the two nuclear powers. It highlights India’s disinformation campaigns, Pakistan’s response strategies, and the erosion of international law in the battle for global perception.